-
Primal Cause Revisited
One of the arguments for the existence of god is a perceived need for a primal cause. Now in my view, a primal cause is… -
That argument won’t fly
by: JT Christian: It strikes me that in your latest, you are turning to wordplay rather than making a valid argument. Perhaps I am missing… -
No, Virginia, it isn’t a sound argument
In spite of the season being nearly three months gone, in order to check something out, I decided to reread after many years Francis P.… -
Circularity
by kkaammeelliiaann If you deny anything’s existence, you must first presuppose its existence in order to argue against it. Therefore in a sense, it already… -
A Hopefully Not Heated Argument
by: Paul W. Sharkey In my initial response to this challenge I was motivated by two factors: First to avoid having to go into a… -
Beware of Exploding Arguments
by: DEI At the end of his otherwise mostly perceptive commentary regarding the agnostic-atheist exchange between our Patriarch and Professor Massimo Pigliucci, Will Petillo offers… -
Far from a slam-dunk argument against God being untestable.
by: Will Petillo Interesting passage you have brought up, but far from a slam-dunk argument against God being untestable. There are, as usual, other parts… -
Six demonstrations that the argument is wrong (or using a sledgehammer to obliterate a gnat.)
by: JT Will: I don’t know why you want to persist in this line of discussion. An axiom that contradictions are acceptable means that whatever…